Land issue puts talks in jeopardy
The genocide talks with Germany may have to refocus, as communities say they want land, which Berlin says it cannot provide.
Namibia's OvaHerero people are heartened that Germany is keen to atone for the genocide of their ancestors, but they expect something Berlin says it is not in a position to give.
“What we want is our land,” said 74-year-old Alex Kautauuapela, whose parents survived the extermination of 80% of the community, a precursor to the Holocaust.
She lives much as they did, in a community dependent on cattle herding.
“The OvaHerero are poor because of German people,” she said, hunched over a walking stick as one of her grandchildren chased a stray dog around her crumbling house in the Herero ancestral homeland of Okahandja north of the capital, Windhoek.
About half of the arable land in the country in south-western Africa, which Germany annexed in 1884 is owned by descendants of German and Dutch immigrants, who make up just 6% of the 2.3 million population.
Land used by the OvaHerero and smaller Nama community for grazing was seized and thousands were executed after they rebelled in 1904. The rest were driven into the country's vast tracts of desert to starve.
The call for land restitution by indigenous groups is mirrored in countries across Africa, and any reparation agreement for the Herero could set a precedent to other groups seeking redress from European colonial powers.
Momentum for a settlement with Namibia increased last year after Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan called Germany hypocritical for recognising massacres of Armenians by Ottoman Turks as genocide, but not confronting its dark past in Namibia.
A month later, in July, German Chancellor Angela Merkel's office said Germany would acknowledge the genocide of the OvaHerero and Nama peoples and offer a formal apology. Five rounds of negotiations have been held since, although German officials emphasise talks have been going on since 2012.
One difficult issue is how to address demands for the return of skulls of victims that were taken to Germany to try to prove racial superiority: Berlin has given some back, but says others are hard to locate. Another sensitive area is calls for monetary compensation.
But front and centre, for the community, is land.
“We are willing to go and take our land,” said Paramount Chief Vekuii Rukoro, who says his followers have been excluded from the talks with Germany.
“We want to be directly in the room with government at negotiations. If the Germans sign on the dotted line without us we will consider it as an act of war,” he told Reuters.
“We won't wait another 100 years for justice.”
“Cleansing”
Another OvaHerero group is being consulted in talks but Rukoro says they are just “puppets” of the Namibian government, which has been dominated by the largest tribe, the Oshiwambo, since independence.
This week, a United Nations expert Group on People of African Descent appeared to back him up. Noting Germany had apologised for the genocide and given aid, it said it regretted Berlin had “thus far not seriously consulted with the lawful representatives of the minority and indigenous victims of that genocide to discuss reparations”.
The German ambassador to Namibia, Christian Matthias Schlaga, acknowledged some OvaHerero groups were not currently engaged in the talks but expressed confidence they could be reintegrated.
“Both governments' clear intention is to reach a result that will be accepted by the communities in question,” Schlaga told Reuters from his office in Windhoek.
Eyeing a possible Namibia deal, Tanzanians have sought compensation from Germany for some 70 000 killed during the Maji-Maji rebellion during colonial rule of German East Africa in the early 20th century.
But Schlaga said any agreement between Berlin and Windhoek would not lead to negotiations in other parts of Africa. “We think the situation in Namibia is very unique,” he said. “This is why we negotiate in this country and nowhere else.”
The unique nature Schlaga refers to is the evidence of German forces' intent to exterminate along ethnic lines. That was spelled out by German General Lothar von Trotha, who was sent by the Kaiser to crush the uprising. “I believe that the (Herero) nation as such should be annihilated,” he wrote. “Only following this cleansing can something new emerge.”
Those who were not shot or starved to death in the desert were captured and placed in concentration camps, where many more died of disease, mistreatment or torture. Up to 100 000 OvaHerero and 10 000 Nama were killed, historians say.
OvaHerero and Nama women were systematically raped by German soldiers and their descendants still face discrimination from members of their tribe who consider themselves 'pure'.
Drawing a line
The grave of Samuel Maharero, who led the Herero's fight against the German colonial army before escaping across the border, lies in an almost inaccessible field in Okahandja amid wandering goats and overgrown foliage.
Just a few hundred metres down the road is an impeccably cared-for graveyard for German soldiers killed in the rebellion. There is no cemetery for the slaughtered Herero, whose bodies were left out in the open.
“We've lost our land, our culture, our tradition,” said one resident.
“The Germans are getting richer and richer from our land.”
Schlaga said Berlin supported efforts by Namibia to redistribute land, but it was the responsibility of the Namibian government to resolve disputes between its nationals.
“Germany has always agreed and supported the Namibian government's decision ... to do a redistribution of land, but based on a principle of willing seller, willing buyer,” he said, noting that land can change hands multiple times over 100 years.
“It is very difficult, if not impossible, to draw a line from the events of 1905 and 1906, to 2017.”
Namibian government sources said one idea was for Germany to provide funds for Namibia to purchase land from any owners willing to sell, but that talks on the issue had stalled.
The government's chief negotiator, Zed Ngavirue, said the 'willing seller, willing buyer' system had failed. The issue would be revisited at a conference this year, he said, but would not be part of the negotiations with Germany over the genocide.
Robert Murtfeld, a US-based academic and independent observer in the Namibian talks, said he did not think an agreement could be reached unless land was included, with implications for other former colonies in Africa.
“Any settlement that would be reached between the German and Namibian governments has to address the issue of land and any decisions hereto could have a trickledown effect for others,” he said. “I believe the chances for a deal being reached are very little.”
- Reuters
Joe Brock
“What we want is our land,” said 74-year-old Alex Kautauuapela, whose parents survived the extermination of 80% of the community, a precursor to the Holocaust.
She lives much as they did, in a community dependent on cattle herding.
“The OvaHerero are poor because of German people,” she said, hunched over a walking stick as one of her grandchildren chased a stray dog around her crumbling house in the Herero ancestral homeland of Okahandja north of the capital, Windhoek.
About half of the arable land in the country in south-western Africa, which Germany annexed in 1884 is owned by descendants of German and Dutch immigrants, who make up just 6% of the 2.3 million population.
Land used by the OvaHerero and smaller Nama community for grazing was seized and thousands were executed after they rebelled in 1904. The rest were driven into the country's vast tracts of desert to starve.
The call for land restitution by indigenous groups is mirrored in countries across Africa, and any reparation agreement for the Herero could set a precedent to other groups seeking redress from European colonial powers.
Momentum for a settlement with Namibia increased last year after Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan called Germany hypocritical for recognising massacres of Armenians by Ottoman Turks as genocide, but not confronting its dark past in Namibia.
A month later, in July, German Chancellor Angela Merkel's office said Germany would acknowledge the genocide of the OvaHerero and Nama peoples and offer a formal apology. Five rounds of negotiations have been held since, although German officials emphasise talks have been going on since 2012.
One difficult issue is how to address demands for the return of skulls of victims that were taken to Germany to try to prove racial superiority: Berlin has given some back, but says others are hard to locate. Another sensitive area is calls for monetary compensation.
But front and centre, for the community, is land.
“We are willing to go and take our land,” said Paramount Chief Vekuii Rukoro, who says his followers have been excluded from the talks with Germany.
“We want to be directly in the room with government at negotiations. If the Germans sign on the dotted line without us we will consider it as an act of war,” he told Reuters.
“We won't wait another 100 years for justice.”
“Cleansing”
Another OvaHerero group is being consulted in talks but Rukoro says they are just “puppets” of the Namibian government, which has been dominated by the largest tribe, the Oshiwambo, since independence.
This week, a United Nations expert Group on People of African Descent appeared to back him up. Noting Germany had apologised for the genocide and given aid, it said it regretted Berlin had “thus far not seriously consulted with the lawful representatives of the minority and indigenous victims of that genocide to discuss reparations”.
The German ambassador to Namibia, Christian Matthias Schlaga, acknowledged some OvaHerero groups were not currently engaged in the talks but expressed confidence they could be reintegrated.
“Both governments' clear intention is to reach a result that will be accepted by the communities in question,” Schlaga told Reuters from his office in Windhoek.
Eyeing a possible Namibia deal, Tanzanians have sought compensation from Germany for some 70 000 killed during the Maji-Maji rebellion during colonial rule of German East Africa in the early 20th century.
But Schlaga said any agreement between Berlin and Windhoek would not lead to negotiations in other parts of Africa. “We think the situation in Namibia is very unique,” he said. “This is why we negotiate in this country and nowhere else.”
The unique nature Schlaga refers to is the evidence of German forces' intent to exterminate along ethnic lines. That was spelled out by German General Lothar von Trotha, who was sent by the Kaiser to crush the uprising. “I believe that the (Herero) nation as such should be annihilated,” he wrote. “Only following this cleansing can something new emerge.”
Those who were not shot or starved to death in the desert were captured and placed in concentration camps, where many more died of disease, mistreatment or torture. Up to 100 000 OvaHerero and 10 000 Nama were killed, historians say.
OvaHerero and Nama women were systematically raped by German soldiers and their descendants still face discrimination from members of their tribe who consider themselves 'pure'.
Drawing a line
The grave of Samuel Maharero, who led the Herero's fight against the German colonial army before escaping across the border, lies in an almost inaccessible field in Okahandja amid wandering goats and overgrown foliage.
Just a few hundred metres down the road is an impeccably cared-for graveyard for German soldiers killed in the rebellion. There is no cemetery for the slaughtered Herero, whose bodies were left out in the open.
“We've lost our land, our culture, our tradition,” said one resident.
“The Germans are getting richer and richer from our land.”
Schlaga said Berlin supported efforts by Namibia to redistribute land, but it was the responsibility of the Namibian government to resolve disputes between its nationals.
“Germany has always agreed and supported the Namibian government's decision ... to do a redistribution of land, but based on a principle of willing seller, willing buyer,” he said, noting that land can change hands multiple times over 100 years.
“It is very difficult, if not impossible, to draw a line from the events of 1905 and 1906, to 2017.”
Namibian government sources said one idea was for Germany to provide funds for Namibia to purchase land from any owners willing to sell, but that talks on the issue had stalled.
The government's chief negotiator, Zed Ngavirue, said the 'willing seller, willing buyer' system had failed. The issue would be revisited at a conference this year, he said, but would not be part of the negotiations with Germany over the genocide.
Robert Murtfeld, a US-based academic and independent observer in the Namibian talks, said he did not think an agreement could be reached unless land was included, with implications for other former colonies in Africa.
“Any settlement that would be reached between the German and Namibian governments has to address the issue of land and any decisions hereto could have a trickledown effect for others,” he said. “I believe the chances for a deal being reached are very little.”
- Reuters
Joe Brock
Comments
Namibian Sun
No comments have been left on this article